In 1 Timothy 2, the writer discusses women, authority, and fear in childbirth. It does not exclude women from being church leaders. This is post 2 of 4, where I look at 1 Timothy 2 where several groups are corrected. I look at the larger context of 1 Timothy here. In it, I look at whether the three pastoral letters were written by Paul or an imitator of Paul, and we look at the qualifications to be a church leader. I discuss 2 Timothy here. and discuss how Scripture is inspired by God. I look at Titus here and discuss an elder's responsibilities to hold to the true message, encourage believers, and refute false teaching. These three letters together are called the pastoral letters.
This is post 2 of 5 on the pastoral letters to Timothy and Titus, examining scholarship and showing these letters do not exclude women from being church leaders.
In this post on 1 Timothy 1, the writer says to stop exploiting others.
In this post on 1 Timothy 2. the writer corrects false doctrine and comforts a woman afraid in childbirth.
In my post on 1 Timothy 3-6, the writer discusses qualifications for church leadership
I discuss 2 Timothy here. I examine Titus here.
1 Timothy 2: Stop Arguing and Showing off, Let a Women Learn, Comfort her
This chapter is not about putting limitations on women. Paul corrects improper behaviours by both men and women and addresses a woman teaching false doctrine by letting her learn and by alleviating her fears.
Paul asks Timothy to pray for all people and ask elders to ensure believers can live peacefully. Such peace and godliness will help bring all people to come to the saving knowledge that there is one God, and one mediator between God and humanity: Jesus Christ who gave himself as a payment to give freedom to men and women.
Therefore, keeping in mind the goal of peace and godliness that will attract people to know God, the writer instructs three groups:
all men to stop the anger, arguing, domineering
all women to stop displaying their wealth and instead display their good works,
one particular woman to learn the true message (v1. 1), stop teaching until she learns the correct doctrine, stop domineering her husband.
Some translations of 1 Timothy 2:11 say women generally (plural) where the original is singular 'a woman'. The men have succumbed to false teaching about anger and arguments. The women have listened to false teaching about wealth and what they should wear. The individual woman may have been the victim of false teachers who targeted only women. Paul says to let her quietly learn the correct doctrine so that she can defend herself from false teachers. Patriarchal readers have been reluctant to see that 1 Timothy corrects the angry and arguing men and tells harsh, undisciplined husbands to be faithful, loving, and self-controlled.
Correct and Restore False Teachers
Bruce C. E. Fleming, the host of the Eden Podcast and Co-Founder of the Tru316 Foundation, states that the main message of 1 Timothy 2 is that we are to correct and restore the men and women overseers who go astray. The male overseers were arguing, the female overseers were overtly showing their wealth, and both groups needed to be corrected. Timothy should stop male and female wayward overseers from teaching false doctrine; let each one first learn quietly.
Let Her Learn Before Teaching
This passage is not about having authority in the church. It could be about a woman usurping a teacher role before being trained. The solution is to let her learn.
The writer is insisting that Timothy silence certain people not to teach false doctrines (1 Timothy 1:3). She is to keep silent until she learns correct doctrine. Like all new believers, she should learn in quietness and submit to teachers. She should not usurp a teacher's role when she has not yet learned correct doctrine,
Dr. Lynn Cohick discusses 1 Timothy on the Local Churchology Podcast (3) The passage in 1 Timothy 2 must be read in the context of 1 Timothy 1, which introduces the discussion on false doctrines. Paul says he isn't permitting a woman to teach until she learns; he is not prohibiting all women from teaching for all time. He wants the woman to keep silent from teaching false doctrine until she learns. She is to be undistracted and focused while she learns. She is not to spread the heresy that celibacy is more pious or holy, and not to dominate or have authority to make her husband celibate. Paul says childbirth will not make a woman impure and being celibate is not more holy. Paul reassures the woman that her salvation by faith is secure despite the birth process if she and her husband both remain in faith and love.
Learning Protects Against False Teachers
Tom Barker sees this author as mainly concerned with false teachings and letting everyone learn. In his interview with the Local Churchology Podcast (4), he explains that creation order has nothing to do with authority; God gave both genders dominion over the earth. Tom Barker believes the letter is addressing issues specific to Ephesus, where Paul placed Timothy as a church overseer. In Ephesus, many trusted the goddess Artemis and women appeared to be targetted by false teachers who encouraged women to turn back to Artemis. If women did not learn correct Christian doctrine, they would be especially vulnerable to false teachers.
Knowing the correct doctrine will protect her from being vulnerable to false teachers who have been targetting women with the idea that they will risk death in childbirth if they turn away from Artemis. Like Eve, liars may deceive her if she does not know the correct doctrine. The writer refers to hypocritical liars who forbid people to marry and who promote abstinence (from food and intimate relations) in 1 Timothy 4:2-5.
What False Teaching?
The woman in 1 Timothy 2:11 may have been the victim of enemy teachers saying Christian women were more likely to die in childbirth because they did not have the protection of Artemis, the goddess of safe childbirth. Paul reassures her that God will keep her safe through the physically risky birth process, and that she should not turn to false gods to save her in her time of crisis. Paul tells Timothy to comfort the woman that God will bring her safely through childbirth.
She may have learned from pagan teachers telling her to imitate the goddess virgin warrior Artemis. If she thought being a virgin was more honoured or a way to earn salvation, she could have been browbeating her husband into celibacy. She may have learned from gnostic female false teachers who said that Eve came first, pursued knowledge, gave Adam life and taught him. Paul corrects the teaching, saying that women don't hold superior knowledge from Eve, that Adam was formed first, and that Eve was deceived. She may have learned from legalistic Jewish teachers that women will be kept pure and holy by being celibate since giving birth is ritually impure. These same legalists taught men must be circumcised. Paul says that God will keep her salvation [by Christ] even through the ritually impure childbirth process, as through a storm (not by a storm).
In my book, The Sword: A Fun Way to Engage in Healthy Debate on What the Bible Says about a Woman's Role, flashcard 38 thrusts the Complementarian argument not to permit any woman to teach or hold any authority over a man, alongside the Egalitarian defence not to allow a woman to spread heresy but first, let her learn!
A Domineering Woman
Theologian Marg Mowczko suggests the passage addresses an individual woman who is domineering her husband (1). The woman may be refusing to have sex with her husband, avoiding sex, or bullying her husband into abstinence. Again, the solution is to let her learn.
In the first century, celibacy was honoured based on both Artemis, goddess of chastity, and the Jewish law, which said a woman became ritually impure after childbirth. Perhaps the woman thought she needed to be celibate even while married in order to remain pure and keep her salvation. Marg Mowczko discusses the theme of virginity in the Acts of Paul and Thecla here (2). The woman teaching this heresy should stop domineering her husband and be assured that she will be kept pure even through childbirth if she and her husband continue in faith and love together (1 Timothy 2).
Domineering or Afraid?
What may have been the false ideas that made her afraid and aggressively warn others to obey? She should not dominate or bully her husband into believing the false doctrine that they should stay celibate. Her husband may have perceived the woman as desiring control when really she was acting out of sheer terror in the false doctrine that only Artemis could keep her safe in childbirth. Often when a person acts out of fear, others can mistake it as aggression or bullying. The letter addresses the root of her fears, which is false teaching, especially circulated by and for women. The solution is not to condemn her but to let her learn so she can defend herself against false teachers, deceivers and liars. Reassure her so she will hold her faith in Christ and not be afraid of pregnancy or childbirth. Comfort her that faith in Christ means she need not be afraid.
Paul Addresses Private Lives Not Community Worship
Dr. Cynthia Long Westfall (5) suggests that this is a personal letter addressing the problems of private individuals. The instructions for men to stop arguing and women to stop showing off their wealth are not related to communal worship services but to how believers live their private lives. The author is concerned about the women in their homes being vulnerable to the risk of false teachers and needing to learn the correct doctrine.
Dr. Cynthia Long Westfall (6) states that 1 Timothy 2:11-15 is not related to our spiritual salvation but to a specific woman who dreads dying in childbirth. Fear of death in childbirth may be what makes the woman avoid sex and insist that her husband abstain. Paul corrects her false teaching that Eve came first, was not deceived, and was wiser than Adam. Paul is concerned that this woman is teaching others to avoid pregnancy and childbirth because followers of Jesus lose the protection of Artemis. Paul is concerned about women turning back to Artemis in their time of crisis, and he wants to reassure and encourage women to rely on Christ to shelter and protect them through the childbearing process. In Westfall's view, the risk of death in childbirth is paramount, and the author is telling the woman she can be saved from turning to idolatry and saved from death in childbirth if they (she and her husband) both continue in faith, love, and self-control. Paul seems to be instructing her husband to be considerate and self-disciplined, which can help reduce maternal mortality.
How can the passage reassure women that God will keep them safe from physical death in childbirth when in fact, women do continue to bear risks in childbearing? Dr. Westfall points out that James tells us to pray for the sick and anoint them with oil (James 5:14-15) even though sometimes the person still is not, in fact, healed. In the same way, we can pray for the woman in labour. Paul writes in a culture where a man did not need to be considerate of his wife, and sometimes it was a husband's physical or sexual treatment of a pregnant wife that contributed to maternal mortality. He reminds both the husband and wife to continue in kindness, support, and self-restraint to help reduce maternal mortality.
Today's False Doctrine Targetting Women
Raised to think that women were designed primarily for delivering, raising and teaching children, Sandra L. Glahn had a crisis of faith after experiencing infertility and pregnancy loss.
She had learned incorrect doctrine that women are saved through childbearing, and feared she would not be able to obey God's call for her to be a mother and her salvation might be at risk. In her book, Nobody's Mother (7) she corrects false teachings about being saved through childhood. It is based on the false idea that Artemis was a goddess of fertility or a nurturing mother with many breasts. Rather, Artemis was a goddess of fertility and a midwife and protector of women. Her many pouches hold magic powder to remove pain and keep women safe through childbirth. Women of ancient Ephesus were afraid to turn away from Artemis and trust Christ.
Who is 'she' and 'they'? (1 Timothy 2:15)
After Paul addresses the individual woman's fear and behaviours based on false doctrine, he switches to addressing the behaviours of a plural group.
"and she shall be saved through the child-bearing, if they remain in faith, and love, and sanctification, with sobriety." 1 Timothy 2:15 Young's Literal Translation
There is confusion on who "she" is in 1 Timothy 2:15. It may be:
women generally in 1 Timothy 2:11-12
the woman Eve in 1 Timothy 2:13-14.
an individual woman addressed in 1 Timothy 2:11-12
In my book, The Sword: A Fun Way to Engage in Healthy Debate on What the Bible Says about a Woman's Role, flashcard 48 thrusts the Complementarian view that God put men in charge, and the Egalitarian defence that God put both in charge as co-rulers.
"She" is "women"; "They" means Women Generally
In some Bible translations, 1 Timothy 2:11-15 is translated as 'women' (plural), obscuring that the original language is singular and addresses a specific woman. Translations showing "women" say that 'women' or 'all women' will be saved through childbirth if women continue in faith and self-control. Some build into their translation the idea of women being saved by having children if the women continue in faith and good behaviour. For example, women will be saved 'by having children' (CEV, ERV), 'women will be preserved if they...' (AMP), and 'women will be saved by having children if they keep...' NIRV. The Living Bible actually infers God intentionally cursed women with pain and women's actions in childbirth save her: "God sent pain and suffering to women when their children are born, but he will save their souls if they trust in him, living quiet, good, and loving lives."
These translations and interpretations infer that God saves women's souls in a different way than God saves men's souls. This view suggests that women are spiritually saved based on behaving correctly, having faith and bearing children. It contradicts Paul's repeated message that we are only saved by faith (Romans 6:23, Ephesians 2:8-9). A patriarchal reading is that this passage does not instruct or make demands on men, only women. They would say it tells women to stay silent and show their virtue by bearing children; no woman should ever teach or have authority over men.
'She' is Eve; 'They' means All Women
Bruce Fleming says the individual woman in 1 Timothy 2:15 relates to the woman, Eve (8). who is named in 1 Timothy 2:13-14. She (the woman/wife) will be saved through the childbirth of Jesus. He explains the true meaning of Genesis 3:16 is that God blessed women by multiplying their ability to conceive. Some Bible interpretations build on this interpretation, saying women are saved 'through the birth of the divine Child' (AMPC), women 'will be saved through the birth of the child if they lead respectable lives' (GW, NOG), 'her childbearing brought about salvation, reversing Eve (MSG). The inference is that sin entered the world with Eve and is overcome by Eve's offspring, the birth of Jesus.
Holding the view that Eve shall be saved by the child-bearing of Mary, it follows that 'they' refers to all women being spiritually saved through the birth of Jesus if they (all women) continue in faith, love, and self-control. It may have been a novel idea that women have souls and could be saved individually. They were adopted into the Abrahamic covenant by the circumcision of their male relatives. In the New Covenant, she is saved by the birth of Christ. Paul tells the Romans, that sin entered the world through Adam, and grace came through one man, Jesus (Romans 5:12-19).
This viewpoint is consistent with passages that assert we are saved only through faith. If it meant all people would be saved by faithfulness, it is unclear why it says they (all women) will be saved by faithfulness.
'She' is an individual woman; 'They' is the Woman and her Husband
As discussed above, the original language of 1 Timothy 2:11 uses the singular, 'a woman'.
Paul may be addressing a specific Ephesus woman who is bullying her husband into celibacy based on her belief in a false doctrine about the risks of childbearing. There is a real possibility that a woman is afraid and wants to be saved physically as well as spiritually.
The plural here may refer to the woman and her husband. Dr. Cynthia Long Westfall (5) suggests a woman is more likely to survive the physical and spiritual struggles of childbirth when a husband shows care and self-control. Ancient tombstones show evidence that it was unusual for husbands to treat their wives kindly since it was considered acceptable to beat a wife. Many women at that time were married at puberty and had five children by the age of 20, and death in childbirth was common. Her safety through childbirth is on the condition that 'they both' remain faithful, loving, and self-disciplined.
This passage is not telling a woman to bear more children; it's telling men to address a woman's aggressive behaviour by comforting her, letting her learn, allaying her fears, being self-disciplined and kind, and reassuring her of God's faithfulness.
This viewpoint is consistent with passages that assert salvation by faith. In addition, it addresses a woman's fear of the physical risks of childbearing and the reliance on a false goddess to bring her safely through this risk. It is also the only viewpoint that shows the writer correcting the behaviour of both women and men, telling the husband to continue in faithfulness and self-control.
Summary of false teachings and interpretations of Timothy 2, beside biblical truths:
False idea | True idea |
Salvation by grace only relates to men | God wants all people to be saved (1 Timothy 2:4). |
Jesus is a mediator for men and not women | Christ's work as a mediator or path to God is for anyone who believes (John 3:16, John 4:14). |
Women are spiritually saved through obedience to men and through bearing children. | Neither women nor men are saved by their own actions, but by God's grace (Titus 3:5, Romans 3:28, Ephesians 2:8-10, Galatians 2:16, Philippians 3:9) |
God commands women to have children. Women of Ephesus were falsely trusting the goddess Artemis. Women should not abandon their ordained roles as mothers by demanding teaching and authoritative positions; women will be fulfilled through childbearing. | God never commands women to have children. God blesses both women and men with the ability to have children when they unite (Genesis 1:22 and 28). Some women have children, some do not. Either way, the childbearing role lasts only a portion of a woman's time on earth. Some women are gifted and fulfilled in roles other than childbearing. Artemis was not a goddess of fertility but of virginity and midwifery. Women should trust Christ, not Artemis, for safety in childbirth. |
God wants women to suffer in childbirth; childbirth will make all women suffer but it will not endanger their spiritual salvation | God did not curse women with childbirth and God does not want humans to suffer. God warned Eve of multiplied effort in working the cursed soil and in bringing forth children. Childbirth does not impact spiritual salvation. |
Women must never have authority over men at home or in community settings. Any woman teaching a man is usurping the authority of men. Men may hold authority if they meet other criteria. Men may overrule, usurp power, or dominate others. | Women (and men) are not to assume authority by usurping power, overruling or domineering. Christians are to be loving, peaceful, patient, kind, gentle, and self-controlled (Galatians 5:22-23). It does not mean a woman cannot have any authority but that any believer cannot force their authority over others. Jesus calls all believers to show their light (Matthew 5), and Paul says all believers are called to freedom (Galatians 5:13), a woman ought to have authority over herself (1 Corinthians 11:10-12), and husbands and wives should yield authority to one another (1 Corinthians 7:4, Ephesians 5:21). |
Paul is upbraiding or correcting women for teaching and having authority over men | Paul is instructing Timothy to let a woman learn, and not permit her to teach until she learns correct doctrine, and not allow her to domineer or bully her husband by teaching false doctrine about the need for celibacy. |
A woman or all women will be spiritually saved by the birth of Christ and by giving birth and women must continue in good behaviour, remaining quiet and obedient | A woman or all women will be spiritually saved by believing in Jesus Christ. Men and women are both saved by belief in Christ. Men and women are both called to live their faith in their behaviour: love, holiness, and self-control. |
Conclusion
In summary, this is a private letter to Timothy, who is in charge of the church in Ephesus. Chapter 2 encourages women to learn correct doctrine so that they are less vulnerable to false teachers. It also alleviates a woman's fears of childbirth and the temptation to turn to Artemis for safety. It does not prohibit anyone from leading or speaking based on gender. It encourages Timothy to live in godliness, to stop the community from spreading false doctrine, and to teach them to live in godliness.
#writerslife #WritingCommunity #womanauthor #womensfictionauthor #womensfiction #inspiration #empoweredwomen #christianfiction #amediting #amwriting #lgbtqally #empoweringwomen #biblicalfiction #biblicalinterpretation #womensupportingwomen #egalitarian #historicalfiction #writer #feministtheology #Christianfeminists #shepreaches #jesusfeminist #whenwomenlead #sheteaches #womensfictionwriter #authorsofinstagram
Elaine Ricker Kelly Author is empowering women with Christian fiction about women in the Bible and early church and Christian blogs about women in leadership, church history and doctrine. Her books include:
Forgotten Followers from Broken to Bold, Book 1
The Sword A Fun Way to Engage in Healthy Debate on What the Bible Says About a Woman's Role
Because She Was Called: from Broken to Bold, Book 2, A Novel of the Early Church, imagines Mary Magdalene's trip to testify before the emperor
Comentários